Search for: All records

The cellular network has undergone rapid progress since its inception in 1980s. While rapid iteration of newer generations of cellular technology plays a key role in this evolution, the incremental and eventually wide deployment of every new technology generation also plays a vital role in delivering the promised performance improvement. In this work, we conduct the first metamorphosis study of a cellular network generation, 5G, by measuring the user-experienced 5G performance from 5G network’s birth (initial deployment) to maturity (steady state). By analyzing a 4-year 5G performance trace of 2.65M+ Ookla® Speedtest Intelligence® measurements collected in 9 cities in the United States and Europe from January 2020 to December 2023, we unveil the detailed evolution of 5G coverage, throughput, and latency at the quarterly granularity, compare the performance diversity across the 9 representative cities, and gain insights into compounding factors that affect user-experienced 5G performance, such as adoption of 5G devices and the load on the 5G network. Our study uncovers the typical life-cycle of a new cellular technology generation as it undergoes its “growing pain” towards delivering its promised QoE over the previous technology generation. 

In 2022, 3 years after the initial 5G rollout, through a cross-country US driving trip (from Los Angeles to Boston), the authors of [28] conducted an in-depth measurement study of user-perceived experience (network coverage, performance, and QoE of a set of major 5G “killer” apps) over all three major US carriers. The study revealed disappointingly low 5G coverage and suboptimal network performance – falling short of the expectations needed to support the new generation of 5G "killer apps. Now, five years into the 5G era, widely considered its midlife, 5G networks are expected to deliver stable and mature performance. In this work, we replicate the 2022 study along the same coast-to-coast route, evaluating the current state of cellular coverage and network and application performance across all three major US operators. While we observe a substantial increase in 5G coverage and a corresponding boost in network performance, two out of three operators still exhibit less than 50% 5G coverage along the driving route even five years after the initial 5G rollout. We expand the scope of the previous work by analyzing key lower-layer KPIs that directly influence the network performance. Finally, we introduce a head-to-head comparison with Starlink’s LEO satellite network to assess whether emerging non-terrestrial networks (NTNs) can complement the terrestrial cellular infrastructure in the next generation of wireless connectivity. 

After a rapid deployment worldwide over the past few years, 5G is expected to have reached a mature deployment stage to provide measurable improvement of network performance and user experience over its predecessors. In this study, we aim to assess 5G deployment maturity via three conditions: (1) Does 5G performance remain stable over a long time span? (2) Does 5G provide better performance than its predecessor LTE? (3) Does the technology offer similar performance across diverse geographic areas and cellular operators? We answer this important question by conducting a cross-sectional, year-long measurement study of 5G uplink performance. Leveraging a custom Android App, we collected 5G uplink performance measurements (of critical importance to latency-critical apps) spanning 8 major cities in 7 countries and two different continents. Our measurements show that 5G deployment in major cities appears to have matured, with no major performance improvements observed over a one-year period, but 5G does not provide consistent, superior measurable performance over LTE, especially in terms of latency, and further there exists clear uneven 5G performance across the 8 cities. Our study suggests that, while 5G deployment appears to have stagnated, it is short of delivering its promised performance and user experience gain over its predecessor. 

The well-known susceptibility of millimeter wave links to human blockage and client mobility has recently motivated researchers to propose approaches that leverage both 802.11ad radios (operating in the 60 GHz band) and legacy 802.11ac radios (operating in the 5 GHz band) in dual-band commercial off-the-shelf devices to simultaneously provide Gbps throughput and reliability. One such approach is via Multipath TCP (MPTCP), a transport layer protocol that is transparent to applications and requires no changes to the underlying wireless drivers. However, MPTCP (as well as other bundling approaches) have only been evaluated to date in 60 GHz WLANs with laptop clients. In this work, we port for first time the MPTCP source code to a dual-band smartphone equipped with an 802.11ad and an 802.11ac radio. We discuss the challenges we face and the system-level optimizations required to enable the phone to support Gbps data rates and yield optimal MPTCP throughput (i.e., the sum of the individual throughputs of the two radios) under ideal conditions. We also evaluate for first time the power consumption of MPTCP in a dual-band 802.11ad/ac smartphone and provide recommendations towards the design of an energy-aware MPTCP scheduler. We make our source code publicly available to enable other researchers to experiment with MPTCP in smartphones equipped with millimeter wave radios.